The Dark Room
Books where the villain gets the girl
Not a moody hero. The actual villain, and the girl who picks him anyway. Retellings, princes of Hell and the enemy side.

Some readers want the hero to be a bit bad. Others want the actual villain: the man the story has spent years telling you to fear, and the girl who picks him anyway. These are books where the villain gets the girl. Sometimes he is a fairy-tale villain, sometimes a prince of Hell, sometimes just the enemy.
What counts as a villain gets the girl book?
For this list, the love interest has to be cast as the villain or the enemy by his own story, not just be moody. That means villain retellings, men from the side the heroine is meant to be fighting, and heroes who are introduced as the threat.

Books where the villain gets the girl
Spice and darkness scores are on each book’s page.
- Hooked by Emily McIntire. Peter Pan, told by Captain Hook. The villain holds the pen, and Wendy is the daughter of his enemy. Book one of Never After. Spice 4, Dark 4.
- Scarred by Emily McIntire. The story behind The Lion King, moved to a royal court, with the villain at its centre. Never After book two. Spice 4, Dark 4.
- Wretched by Emily McIntire. Never After book three. Revenge, enemies to lovers and a morally grey hero. Spice 5, Dark 4.
- Kingdom of the Wicked by Kerri Maniscalco. A witch summons Wrath, one of the princes of Hell, to find her sister’s killer. Book one is a slow burn. Spice 1, Dark 3.
- The Cruel Prince by Holly Black. Cardan is the cruel prince of the title and Jude’s tormentor long before he’s anything else. Closed door, almost entirely. Spice 1, Dark 3.
- Alchemised by SenLinYu. The war is over and the good side lost. Helena ends up in the hands of Kaine Ferron, from the side that won. Spice 3, Dark 5.
- Haunting Adeline by H. D. Carlton. He is the stalker in the shadows of her house. In most books he would be the villain. Here he is the love story. Spice 5, Dark 5.
Why the villain works
A hero has to be good to get the girl. A villain only has to want her. That’s the fantasy: being chosen by the one person who doesn’t follow anyone’s rules, and who changes nothing about himself except for her. I wrote more about that in the morally grey hero, explained.
The catch is the same as with any dark hero. A villain stays a villain. Check the warnings before you fall for him: every book above has a trigger warnings page.
If you want more, try the morally grey heroes list or books like The Cruel Prince.
FAQ
What are some books where the villain gets the girl?
Hooked and Scarred by Emily McIntire, Kingdom of the Wicked by Kerri Maniscalco, The Cruel Prince by Holly Black, Alchemised by SenLinYu and Haunting Adeline by H. D. Carlton.
Is a villain romance the same as a morally grey hero?
Not quite. A morally grey hero does bad things for reasons you can follow. A villain romance casts him as the enemy of the story, and the heroine chooses him anyway.
What is a villain retelling?
A fairy tale or classic told from the villain’s side, with the villain as the romantic lead. Emily McIntire’s Never After series is the best-known dark romance example.
Which villain romance is the least spicy?
The Cruel Prince and Kingdom of the Wicked both score Spice 1 here. Hooked and Wretched are much spicier.
On the shelf
The books this essay is standing next to. Notes on those pages are original. The warnings are there before the plot.
Essays are opinion. They are not a substitute for an author’s own warning note. Patreon · Ko-fi · Library