Editorial policy
Editorial policy and corrections
This is how the shelf is put together, and what happens when it is wrong.
Where the facts come from
Sources rank in this order:
- The author's own site or content-warning page.
- The publisher or imprint page and the official retailer listing.
- Library catalogues and ISBN databases, such as Open Library, Google Books and the Library of Congress.
- Goodreads series pages, for series order and first-publication date only.
- StoryGraph, Romance.io, Book Trigger Warnings and Trigger Warning Database, for community-reported warnings only.
Reputable press and author interviews also count. Reviewer blogs are used only for checkable details. AI summary sites are not sources.
How warnings are labelled
The author's own list wins. A page that uses it says "Verified from author's content notes" and gives the source and the date checked. A list from readers says "Community-sourced", names the service and says it is not yet verified against the author's own list. A book with neither says "Warnings not yet verified" and sends you to the author's note. Third-party flags are always reader-reported and unverified.
Where a lead starts under 18 in the book's own synopsis or the author's FAQ, the page says so plainly, once, with the author's own age line where there is one. Where only readers report it, the book carries the flag "possible young characters, unconfirmed". Flags are never softened and never guessed at.
Scores, endings and read-alikes
Spice and darkness are our own 1 to 5 scales, kept apart and defined on how we rate. They are shelf judgements, not an average of other sites' ratings and not a moral score.
Endings and Kindle Unlimited are flagged only where marked. Blank means not marked, not "no". Read-alikes share tropes, spice, darkness and warnings, with no more than two from one author. Dark romance without SA uses only books checked against the author's own list.
How pages are made
Most shelf notes are generated from structured data and say "Summary compiled from public sources". Researched pages carry the byline "Shelf note by Zade Masked" and lists its sources with the date checked.
A claim on a researched page should trace to a source named on that page. If one does not, that is an error, and a report is welcome.
We do not reproduce reviews or publisher blurbs. Summaries are in our own words, and our rewrite check rejects any run of six or more words from a blurb or review, apart from titles and proper names. An author's content-warning labels may be listed, with attribution.
Corrections
You can report an error on any page through report it on the corrections form. For a missing book, use suggest. The claim is checked against the author's site, the publisher or another primary source. If it is confirmed, the data and the page are changed. We do not promise a reply time.
Covers are the publishers' and authors' artwork, shown small to identify the book. Copyright stays with the rights holder. A rights holder or author can ask through report it on the corrections form for a cover or a flag to be reviewed.
Questions readers actually ask
What does reader-reported mean?
The flag comes from a community service, not the author, and we have not verified it.
Why does a book say Warnings not yet verified?
We have found neither an author list nor a community list. Check the author's own note.
Do you copy reviews?
No. Summaries are in our own words, and a rating from another site is dated and attributed.