The Dark Room

Book age ratings: what age Fourth Wing, ACOTAR and The Cruel Prince are for

Who each book was published for, how spicy and dark it really is, and why our answer is always cautious.

3 min read By Zade Masked

Official covers of Fourth Wing, A Court of Thorns and Roses, The Cruel Prince, Powerless and Throne of Glass on a dark gothic background

“What age is Fourth Wing for?” is one of the most common questions that lands on this site. Parents ask it. So do sixteen-year-olds who have seen the book everywhere. Here’s an honest answer for the books people ask about most: who the publisher made each book for, and how spicy and dark it is on our scale.

Official age ratings vs our age ratings

Books don’t get official age ratings the way films do. What exists is the publisher’s audience (young adult, new adult or adult), sometimes an age range on a retailer listing, and independent guides such as Common Sense Media. Our book pages give a separate call, which is always 18+ on this shelf, because this is a dark romance site and we’d rather be cautious. The spice and darkness scores are the useful part. They tell you what is actually on the page.

Official covers of Fourth Wing, A Court of Thorns and Roses, The Cruel Prince, Powerless and Throne of Glass on a dark gothic background

Book age ratings at a glance

  • Fourth Wing by Rebecca Yarros. Published as new adult and adult fantasy, not YA. Common Sense Media says 16+. Our scores: Spice 4, Dark 3. Two explicit scenes, a lot of violence and swearing. See the Fourth Wing spicy chapters.
  • Iron Flame by Rebecca Yarros. Same audience as Fourth Wing, but more explicit. Spice 4, Dark 3.
  • A Court of Thorns and Roses by Sarah J. Maas. First shelved as YA in the US. Bloomsbury moved the series to its adult list in 2020. Spice 3, Dark 3, and later books go further.
  • The Cruel Prince by Holly Black. Published as young adult by Little, Brown Books for Young Readers. Spice 1, Dark 3: almost no sex on the page, plenty of cruelty and violence.
  • Powerless by Lauren Roberts. Simon & Schuster lists it for ages 14 and up. Spice 1, Dark 2: kissing and a death-game plot.
  • Throne of Glass by Sarah J. Maas. Published as young adult by Bloomsbury in 2012. Common Sense Media says 14+. Spice 1, Dark 2 for book one. The later books are more explicit. See the Throne of Glass reading order.
  • Quicksilver by Callie Hart. Adult. Spice 4, Dark 4.
  • Twisted Love by Ana Huang. Adult. Spice 4, Dark 3.
  • Lights Out by Navessa Allen. Adult, with a long list of kink warnings. Spice 4, Dark 3.
  • Haunting Adeline by H. D. Carlton. Adult only. The author’s own note at the front says so. Spice 5, Dark 5, the top of both scales.

More age ratings readers look up

The answer is the same for each of these. The scores and warnings are the useful part.

How to read the two scores

Spice is how much sex is on the page, from 1 (closed door, or close to it) to 5 (scorching). Darkness is how heavy the world is, from 1 (moody) to 5 (no light). A book can be low on one and high on the other. The Cruel Prince is Spice 1 and Dark 3. That is why one number is never enough. The full scales are on how we rate.

The warnings matter more than the number

An age range cannot tell you whether a book has the one thing a reader cannot handle. Every book above has a trigger warnings page on this site, grouped by how graphic each warning is. Start at trigger warnings A to Z. If you want romantasy with less heat, try low spice dark romance.

FAQ

What age is Fourth Wing appropriate for?

It is published as adult or new adult fantasy. Common Sense Media says 16+. It has two explicit scenes.

What is The Cruel Prince age rating?

It was published as young adult. It has very little sex on the page (Spice 1 on our scale) but a lot of cruelty and violence (Dark 3).

What is the Powerless age rating?

Simon & Schuster lists Powerless for ages 14 and up. It scores Spice 1 and Dark 2 here.

Is A Court of Thorns and Roses YA?

Not any more. It was first shelved as YA in the US, and Bloomsbury moved it to its adult list in 2020. The books have open-door sex scenes.

Why does this site call every book 18+?

Because it’s a dark romance site, and our call is deliberately cautious. Use the spice and darkness scores, and the warnings, to judge a book for yourself.

On the shelf

The books this essay is standing next to. Notes on those pages are original. The warnings are there before the plot.

Newsletter

The next essay, not a drip campaign

One email when there is something worth sending. New parts, shelf notes, nothing else. UK list. No selling your address.

Essays are opinion. They are not a substitute for an author’s own warning note. Patreon · Ko-fi · Library

Buy me a coffee on Ko-fiKo-fi New part · The mask stays on. New part Join on PatreonJoin