The Dark Room

Haunting Adeline, reviewed by the villain

I read the book everyone warns each other about from the wrong side of the window. The video is here, and so is the short version for anyone who'd rather read.

6 min read By Zade Masked Updated

Official covers of Haunting Adeline, Lights Out, Pen Pal and Butcher & Blackbird on a dark gothic background, for Haunting Adeline, reviewed by the villain

Millions of people call Haunting Adeline the most disturbing book on BookTok. Half of them loved it. The other half want it burned. And nearly every review lands on the same line: no real man would ever do this.

So the villain read it. Every page, every rose, every window. It's my first long video, and it's below. If you'd rather read than watch, the short version follows, with timestamps so you can jump straight to the part you care about.

Haunting Adeline, reviewed by the villain (28:17). Plays from youtube-nocookie.com.

A warning first, because this one earns it. The book goes to very heavy places: stalking, murder, violence, human trafficking, abuse, and scenes where consent is broken or blurred. The spicy chapters are listed, with the warnings first, in the Haunting Adeline spicy chapters guide. The video covers the setup and the themes. It doesn't give away the ending, and it describes nothing graphic. If you need them before anything else, the full Haunting Adeline trigger warnings are here.

The house comes first (2:13)

Everything in this book starts with Parsons Manor. Adeline Reilly writes thrillers, and she inherits her grandmother's house. It's big, old and miles from anyone, with far too many windows. Her mother doesn't want her there. She moves in anyway, and finds the diaries of her great-grandmother, Gigi, about a man who watched her generations ago.

That's the shape of the whole book. One woman in the past, writing about being watched. One in the present, reading those pages while someone watches her. It's the old gothic recipe, the one Rebecca and Jane Eyre use. The difference is that this man doesn't stay politely in the background.

Adeline is the reason to read it (4:40)

People talk about her as if she's only the thing he wants. She isn't. She calls the police. She buys a gun. She talks back. And she writes thrillers for a living, so part of her is terrified and part of her is taking notes. I came for the man in the garden. I stayed for her.

The man in the mask (6:55)

Zade Meadows is more than a watcher in a garden. He's a hacker who runs an organisation that hunts human traffickers, and that second storyline drags the book somewhere much darker than roses on a windowsill. It also leaves you with an uncomfortable question. If a man is this dangerous and he points it at the right people, does that make him better? Or just more dangerous?

I score his technique in the video. Patience: ten. Presence: nine. Subtlety: two. My honest view is that he isn't written to be a real man at all. He's a feeling with a mask on.

Three moments from his side of the glass (10:12)

This is the part nobody else does. I take three moments, the first rose, the night she calls the police and the diary, and look at each from where he was standing. Nothing graphic. Just perspective. The diary is the one thing in that house he can't control, and that's the bit I find most interesting.

Why BookTok lost its mind, and whether the hate is fair (12:11, 15:07)

I count three reasons it blew up. The dare, because "do not read this book" is the best advert anyone ever wrote. The shock. And the fights in the comments. There's a fourth, if you'll let me: a plain gothic cover that looked like a horror novel.

Some of the criticism is fair. It's a long book, it sags in the middle, and the writing is uneven. The big one, that it glamorises stalking, gets a straight answer from me. Dark fiction is a locked room, not a manual. Inside the book, the author can go anywhere. Outside it, consent is everything. Where the critics have it right is the marketing. Plenty of readers picked it up off a fifteen-second clip and never saw the warning at the front. That's why every book on this site lists its warnings before the plot.

Official covers of Haunting Adeline, Lights Out, Pen Pal and Butcher & Blackbird on a dark gothic background, for Haunting Adeline, reviewed by the villain

The film (17:53)

A Haunting Adeline film is in development, and H. D. Carlton says she has a say in the script and casting. When I recorded, no studio, director, cast names or release date had been announced, and anything you've heard beyond that is reported, not confirmed. I give my guess in the video. The latest confirmed facts live on the Haunting Adeline movie page, and I keep it up to date.

My verdict and scores (20:52)

  • Atmosphere: 9/10. The house, the rain, the diaries. The book's real strength.
  • Adeline: 8/10. A heroine with a spine and a sense of humour.
  • Zade, as a character: 7/10. Magnetic, but a little too perfect.
  • Plot and pacing: 6/10. Two strong storylines, a saggy middle and a cliffhanger ending.
  • Darkness: 5/5. As dark as the genre goes.

It isn't the best-written dark romance. It isn't even the darkest. But it's the most important one of the last few years. The full breakdown is on the Haunting Adeline book page.

Hunting Adeline, Does It Hurt?, Obsession, Stalk Her and more are on my list of ten books like Haunting Adeline, each with a darkness score and its warnings. Not sure which villain is yours? Take the which dark romance villain is yours? quiz and get a reading list to match.

Should you read it? (25:15)

Read it if you want obsession turned all the way up, if you can handle very heavy content, and if you read the warnings first. Actually first. Skip it if you want a sweet love story, or if dark material stays with you for days. Either way, know that it ends on a cliffhanger, and book two is darker.

Tell me under the video which book I should read next. The darker the better. I've cleared my evenings.

Video chapters

  1. 0:00 The villain has notes
  2. 0:35 Who I am, and the warnings
  3. 2:13 Parsons Manor
  4. 4:40 Adeline, the girl in the window
  5. 6:55 The man in the mask
  6. 10:12 Three moments, from his side of the glass
  7. 12:11 Why BookTok lost its mind
  8. 14:29 Ratings and warnings
  9. 15:07 Is the hate fair?
  10. 17:53 The film: everything we know
  11. 20:52 The villain's verdict
  12. 23:35 Books like Haunting Adeline
  13. 25:15 Should you read it?
  14. 26:56 Verdict
  15. 27:24 Who I am, and where to find me

Haunting Adeline review FAQ

Is Haunting Adeline worth reading?

Yes if you want obsession turned all the way up and you can handle very heavy content. Read the trigger warnings first. Skip it if you want a sweet love story, or if dark material stays with you for days. It ends on a cliffhanger, and book two is darker.

Does this Haunting Adeline review spoil the ending?

No. The video and this post cover the setup and the themes only. Nothing graphic, and the ending is not given away.

Is there a Haunting Adeline movie?

A film is in development. H. D. Carlton has said she has a say in the script and casting. No studio, director, cast names or release date had been announced when the video was recorded. Confirmed facts are kept on the Haunting Adeline movie page.

What should I read after Haunting Adeline?

Hunting Adeline, Does It Hurt?, Obsession, Stalk Her and more are on the ten books like Haunting Adeline list, each with a darkness score and its warnings. Or take the which dark romance villain is yours? quiz for a personalised list.

On the shelf

The books this essay is standing next to. Notes on those pages are original. The warnings are there before the plot.

Newsletter

The next essay, not a drip campaign

One email when there is something worth sending. New parts, shelf notes, nothing else. UK list. No selling your address.

Essays are opinion. They are not a substitute for an author’s own warning note. Patreon · Ko-fi · Library

Buy me a coffee on Ko-fiKo-fi New part · The mask stays on. New part Join on PatreonJoin