The Dark Room
Lights Out vs Haunting Adeline: which masked stalker should you let in first?
Two masked men, two women who ought to lock their doors, and two books that get recommended to every dark romance reader in the same breath.

They are not the same book. Not even close.
Type “lights out vs” into Google and the first suggestion is Haunting Adeline. Type “haunting adeline vs” and Lights Out turns up straight away. So plenty of people are stuck choosing between them. I’ll answer it properly, with the scores and the warnings out in the open, because the wrong one on the wrong night can put someone off the whole genre.
The short answer
Lights Out is the doorway. Haunting Adeline is the basement.
Lights Out by Navessa Allen scores spice 4 of 5 and darkness 3 of 5 on my shelf. It’s funny, it’s filthy, and it ends happily.
Haunting Adeline by H. D. Carlton scores spice 5 of 5 and darkness 5 of 5. It doesn’t pull a single punch, and it ends on a cliffhanger.
If you’re new, start with Lights Out. If you’ve already read it and you want something that properly frightens you, Haunting Adeline is waiting. Read its warnings first, though.
Side by side
| Lights Out | Haunting Adeline | |
|---|---|---|
| Author | Navessa Allen | H. D. Carlton |
| First out | 14 February 2024 | 12 August 2021 |
| Series | Into Darkness, book 1 of 3 | Cat and Mouse, book 1 of 2 |
| Spice | 4/5 (Explicit) | 5/5 (Scorching) |
| Darkness | 3/5 (Dark) | 5/5 (No light) |
| Ending | HEA | Cliffhanger |
| Length | 338 pages self-published, 416 in the Zando edition | about 606 to 608 pages self-published, 624 in the Zando paperback |
| Screen news | Netflix TV series in development | Film in development |
Those numbers come straight from the book pages in my library, where the page counts and dates are explained in full.
The masked men
Josh Hammond in Lights Out posts masked thirst traps for an audience of millions. Aly Cappellucci is a trauma nurse who follows masked men online, and she leaves a comment saying she’d like one to break into her house in a mask. Josh reads that as an invitation. The publisher describes him as going from predator to protector, and Deadline calls him a masked vigilante hacker. The real threat in the book is someone else entirely, a separate figure who has noticed Aly for far worse reasons.
That’s the big difference. In Lights Out, the hero’s game is one she asked for.
Zade Meadows in Haunting Adeline is the Shadow, the stalker who watches, waits and won’t let her go. Adeline Reilly moves into her family’s secluded mansion and runs into him while she’s looking into her great-grandmother’s death. Nobody invited Zade in. That’s what he’s for. I’ve written a full guide to who Zade Meadows is if you want more on the man who made masks mandatory on BookTok.
How spicy is each one?
Both are explicit. Neither is shy about it.
Lights Out is a 4. The sex is on the page and clearly written, and the author names her kinks plainly: breath play, knife play, gun play, fear play, primal play and mask play. If you want the detail, my Lights Out spicy chapters guide goes through it.
Haunting Adeline is a 5. It’s frequent, it’s graphic, and it’s the point of a lot of chapters. The series page names degradation, gun play and somnophilia among its kinks. There’s a Haunting Adeline spicy chapters guide as well.
If heat is your only question, Haunting Adeline wins. It never is the only question, which is why I score darkness separately.
How dark is each one?
This is where they split.
Lights Out is a 3. Harm is part of the story, but the heaviest items on the author’s own list are marked as mentioned, off page or remembered: an off-page rape mention, past domestic abuse, remembered child abuse. The tone is comic. Penguin Random House sells it as a dark romcom, and that’s fair.
I keep Haunting Adeline at Darkness 5 out of 5. Carlton's own warnings name non/dub con between the main characters, stalking, graphic violence, human trafficking, child trafficking, child sacrifice, mentions of child death and explicit sexual situations. Reader content notes add rape and torture. The longer list, with graphic rape, self-harm and grooming, belongs to Hunting Adeline. I wouldn't confuse a shorter warning list with an easier book.
I’m not listing all that to scare you off. I like that this genre lets a book go that far. I just want you to go in knowing, instead of finding out at chapter twelve.
The full lists are grouped by how graphic each warning is:
The endings
Lights Out ends with an HEA. You can read it on its own and close it satisfied.
Haunting Adeline ends on a cliffhanger, and the author’s own note says so. Have Hunting Adeline ready before you finish, because that’s the book that completes the duet. If you’re weighing those two up, I compared them in Haunting Adeline vs Hunting Adeline.
Reading order for each series
Into Darkness follows a new couple in each book: Lights Out (2024), Caught Up (2025) and Game On (2026). I’ve found no source that says you must read them in order. The full list is on the Into Darkness series page.
Cat and Mouse is tighter. The duet is the two Adeline books. Around them sit the prequel Phantom, the novella Satan’s Affair, which the publisher suggests reading first but isn’t required, and the connected standalone Where’s Molly. The order is on the Cat and Mouse series page.
The screen news
Both are heading for the screen, which is half the reason this question keeps coming up.
Deadline reported on 11 February 2026 that Netflix is developing a TV series of Lights Out, with Hannah Schneider as showrunner, writer and executive producer. I’ve found no casting or air date yet.
H. D. Carlton confirmed in July 2026 that a Haunting Adeline film is in development, and she says she has a say in the script, casting, music and set design. It is not a Netflix project, whatever TikTok tells you. Everything that’s actually confirmed is on my Haunting Adeline movie page.
So which one should you read?
Read Lights Out if you want a masked man, real heat, a laugh, and a hero whose game is consensual even when it looks like it isn’t. It’s the best first step into masked stalker romance I know.
Read Haunting Adeline if you’ve got a few dark books behind you already and you want the one that started a thousand arguments. Read the warnings, have Hunting Adeline ready, and don’t start it at 2am in an empty house.
Read both, in that order, if you want to feel how far this genre can stretch.
If you want more of the same, try my masked hero romance list, the stalker romance books guide, or the books I’d hand you next after Lights Out or Haunting Adeline. Everything else by each author lives on the Navessa Allen and H. D. Carlton pages.
FAQ
Is Lights Out darker than Haunting Adeline?
No. Lights Out scores darkness 3 of 5 on my shelf. Haunting Adeline scores 5 of 5, the top of the scale.
Is Lights Out like Haunting Adeline?
In the setup, yes. Both have a masked stalker hero. In tone, no. Lights Out is a dark romcom with an HEA, and Haunting Adeline is pitch black and ends on a cliffhanger.
Which is spicier, Lights Out or Haunting Adeline?
Haunting Adeline. It scores spice 5 of 5. Lights Out scores 4 of 5, which is still explicit.
Should I read Lights Out or Haunting Adeline first?
If you’re new to dark romance, Lights Out. Its heaviest warnings are mentioned or off page, and the tone is funny.
Is Haunting Adeline a standalone?
No. It’s book one of the Cat and Mouse duet and ends on a cliffhanger. Hunting Adeline finishes the story.
Do I have to read the Into Darkness books in order?
Each book follows a new couple, and I’ve found no source that says you must. Lights Out is book one, so it’s the natural start.
Before you go
If you’ve finished both and you’re still not done with masked men, I write one myself. My serial, Behind the Mask, is on Patreon. A man who notices everything, who checks doors and never saves numbers. And if you’d like the next comparison in your inbox, join The Dark Romance Weekly. One email when there’s something worth sending. Nothing else.
On the shelf
The books this essay is standing next to. Notes on those pages are original. The warnings are there before the plot.
Essays are opinion. They are not a substitute for an author’s own warning note. Patreon · Ko-fi · Library

