Sinners of Hawthorne University · 2020
When Sinners PlaySpice level, tropes & is it dark romance?
by Eva Ashwood
Spice 4/5 (Explicit) · Darkness 5/5 (No light) · 6 trigger warnings flagged
From Eva Ashwood, 2020: When Sinners Play, book 1 of Sinners of Hawthorne University. The pull here is mafia, bully, academy, why choose and enemies to lovers. We score it spice 4 (explicit) and darkness 5 (pitch black). The heaviest flags readers report are sexual assault, bullying, abuse. Our scores lean on what readers report, not on a full reread, so treat them as a guide. This note is ours. It is not a publisher blurb.
First published: 2020. Book 1 of Sinners of Hawthorne University.
When Sinners Play tropes
On this shelf, When Sinners Play is filed under Mafia dark romance, Bully romance, Dark academy romance, Why choose / reverse harem and Enemies to lovers. Each tag opens more books with that trope.
When Sinners Play spice level
Is When Sinners Play dark romance?
Yes, at the very dark end. When Sinners Play scores 5 of 5 on our darkness scale (No light).
Spice and darkness are separate scores. More no light books. How we rate.
When Sinners Play trigger warnings
Book-specific flags taken from reader-submitted content warnings on The StoryGraph (top flag reported by 6 readers), grouped by us. Also on that list: suicide, panic attacks/disorders, classism, sexual content, mental illness. See the reader-submitted list.
Graphic (4) — open before you read
Open this before you read. These are the flags most likely to be a hard stop.
Minor (0)
Present, and usually not the reason someone puts the book down.
None flagged in this band.
Full When Sinners Play trigger warnings
Sinners of Hawthorne University reading order
When Sinners Play is book 1 of 1 in Eva Ashwood's Sinners of Hawthorne University series. Start here.
- Book 1 When Sinners Play (this book) · 2020
Order checked against the StoryGraph Sinners of Hawthorne University series page on 13 October 2026.
Who it's for
Shelf note written for this site. We do not copy reviews or publisher blurbs. Outbound links are search pages, not quoted ratings. Kindle Unlimited and endings are only flagged when we were willing to mark them. How we rate.
Missing a book? Suggest it.
Books like When Sinners Play
Matched on shared tropes, then the closest spice and darkness scores. Other books in the same series are listed above, not here.
- Liar
Liar
Tate James
Spice ●●●●○Dark ●●●●○
Shared: Mafia dark romance, Why choose / reverse harem
- Pack Darling - Part One
Pack Darling - Part One
Lola Rock
Spice ●●●●○Dark ●●●●○
Shared: Mafia dark romance, Dark academy romance
- You're Next
You're Next
Tate James
Spice ●●●●○Dark ●●●●○
Shared: Mafia dark romance, Why choose / reverse harem
- Chasing Temptation
Chasing Temptation
Tracy Lorraine
Spice ●●●●○Dark ●●●○○
Shared: Bully romance, Mafia dark romance
- Corrupt Union
Corrupt Union
Tracy Lorraine
Spice ●●●●○Dark ●●●○○
Shared: Bully romance, Mafia dark romance
- Dark Knight
Dark Knight
J. L. Beck
Spice ●●●●○Dark ●●●○○
Shared: Bully romance, Mafia dark romance
- Pretty Little Savage: A Dark Enemies to Lovers College Romance
Pretty Little Savage: A Dark Enemies to Lovers College Romance
Lucy Smoke
Spice ●●●●○Dark ●●●○○
Shared: Bully romance, Mafia dark romance
- Dukes of Ruin
Dukes of Ruin
Angel Lawson
Spice ●●●○○Dark ●●●○○
Shared: Bully romance, Why choose / reverse harem
Books like When Sinners Play, with a reason for each
Questions readers actually ask
What is the spice level of When Sinners Play?
When Sinners Play spice level is 4 of 5 (Explicit). On-page sex, clearly written. Darkness is a separate score: 5 of 5 (No light).
What are the When Sinners Play trigger warnings?
Graphic: Sexual assault, Bullying, Abuse, Blood. Moderate: Death, Grief. Minor: none flagged. These are book-specific flags reported by readers on reader-submitted content warnings on The StoryGraph (top flag reported by 6 readers), grouped by us. The author's own note may list more. Read it before you start.
Is When Sinners Play dark romance?
Yes, at the very dark end. When Sinners Play scores 5 of 5 on our darkness scale (No light). The book is not interested in pulling the punch.
What tropes are in When Sinners Play?
On this shelf When Sinners Play is filed under Mafia dark romance, Bully romance, Dark academy romance, Why choose / reverse harem and Enemies to lovers.
Who is When Sinners Play for?
Pick this up if you want mafia and bully with explicit spice. Read the warnings first.
What are some books like When Sinners Play?
Matched on shared tropes and similar spice and darkness: Liar by Tate James; Pack Darling - Part One by Lola Rock; You're Next by Tate James; Chasing Temptation by Tracy Lorraine; Corrupt Union by Tracy Lorraine; Dark Knight by J. L. Beck. More read-alikes, each with a reason, are on zademasked.com/like/when-sinners-play.
Is When Sinners Play a standalone?
No. When Sinners Play is book 1 of 1 in the Sinners of Hawthorne University series by Eva Ashwood.
What order should I read the Sinners of Hawthorne University series in?
1. When Sinners Play.
How many books are in the Sinners of Hawthorne University series?
The Sinners of Hawthorne University series by Eva Ashwood has 1 main book.
What is the When Sinners Play age rating?
We'd say 18+. Spice sits at 4/5 (explicit) and darkness at 5/5 (no light). That's our recommendation, not an official rating, so read the trigger warnings as well.
Join on Patreon for the Zade Masked serial.