Monster Holidays · 2023
Knotty ListSpice level, tropes & is it dark romance?
by Taylor Fox
Spice 5/5 (Scorching) · Darkness 3/5 (Dark) · 5 trigger warnings flagged
New Obernzell has a Krampus problem, or thinks it does. People have been attacked. The town blames the monster in the woods. Someone suggests the old answer: give him a person. Olivia is only visiting, which makes her the obvious choice.
New Obernzell picks a visitor
She is dragged into the forest, tied up and left for him. Krampus comes, as promised. He does not kill her. He takes her back to his lair. Raunchy Reads describes a horned, very large, very blue holiday monster, and the rest of the book is what he does with the human a town handed him. It is a captive and sacrifice story that leans fully into monster romance.
What Krampus does with her
The captivity begins without her consent. The threat in the town is real, not only the threat in the woods. Once she is in the lair the romance turns warm, which is why the darkness sits mid-scale rather than at the top. The cruelty mostly belongs to the humans who tied her to a tree.
Monster Holidays book one
Taylor Fox self-published Knotty List on 26 November 2023. It opens the Monster Holidays series, which runs to three books, each built around a holiday creature. The paperback carries the subtitle A Dark Holiday Romance, while the Kindle edition calls it A Monster Romance.
It sits among the darker Christmas titles, and the sacrifice setup is the hook: the town chooses her, the woods take her, and the lair is where the romance actually starts. That is useful context if you are deciding between a cosy monster and a captivity start. This one opens as captivity.
Explicit to the top of the scale
Spice is 5, as explicit as the scale runs. The title is a pun that tells you which monster romance conventions to expect, and the book delivers them. If you have not read monster romance before, this is not a gentle start. Darkness is 3: the sacrifice and the bondage are on the page, and readers report more, but the romance itself softens once she is in the lair.
Captivity and the town's cruelty
The book puts these on the page:
- captivity, after she is left as a sacrifice
- bondage and kink
Readers also report violence and death in the town, references to the murder of children, and racism. Taylor Fox has not published a warning list, so treat those three as reader reports.
For readers already into monsters
Take it if you want Christmas to be strange rather than sweet, and you are already happy with monster romance. If you want the stalker version of the season instead, read A Very Stalker Christmas. For more creatures, the monster romance list and monster trope page carry on from here, and the Krampus season is one entry on the Christmas dark romance list.
Knotty List tropes
On this shelf, Knotty List is filed under Monster romance, Captive romance and Dark fantasy romance. Each tag opens more books with that trope.
Knotty List spice level
Is Knotty List dark romance?
Yes. Knotty List scores 3 of 5 on our darkness scale (Dark).
Spice and darkness are separate scores. More dark books. How we rate.
Knotty List trigger warnings
Warnings not yet verified. We could not find the author's own content warning list for this book, so the flags here are only what the publisher's description makes clear. Check the author's note before you start.
Graphic (0): open before you read
Open this before you read. These are the flags most likely to be a hard stop.
None flagged in this band.
Full Knotty List trigger warnings
Monster Holidays reading order
Knotty List is book 1 of 1 in Taylor Fox's Monster Holidays series. Start here.
- Book 1 Knotty List (this book) · 2023
Order checked against the Amazon Monster Holidays series page on 5 November 2026.
Is Knotty List on Kindle Unlimited?
Taylor Fox is marked here as an author who often enrols titles in Kindle Unlimited. That is a shelf note, not a live Amazon check. Confirm on Amazon before you assume this book is included. More Kindle Unlimited dark romance.
Shelf notes are compiled from public sources and reader reports. Flags marked reader-reported are unverified. Outbound links are search pages, not quoted ratings. Kindle Unlimited and endings are only flagged when we were willing to mark them. How we rate.
Missing a book? Suggest it. Spotted a mistake? Report a correction.
Books like Knotty List
Matched on shared tropes, then the closest spice and darkness scores. Other books in the same series are listed above, not here.
- Monsters Are Hidden
Monsters Are Hidden
Alta Hensley
Spice ●●●●●Dark ●●●●○
Shared: Captive romance, Dark fantasy romance
- Neon Gods
Neon Gods
Katee Robert
Spice ●●●●●Dark ●●●○○
Shared: Dark fantasy romance, Monster romance
- Curse That Binds
Curse That Binds
Laura Thalassa
Spice ●●●●●Dark ●●●○○
Shared: Dark fantasy romance, Monster romance
- Learn My Lesson
Learn My Lesson
Katee Robert
Spice ●●●●●Dark ●●●○○
Shared: Dark fantasy romance, Monster romance
- Wicked Webs
Wicked Webs
Raven Kennedy
Spice ●●●●●Dark ●●●○○
Shared: Dark fantasy romance, Captive romance
- Elegant Sins
Elegant Sins
Alta Hensley
Spice ●●●●●Dark ●●●●○
Shared: Captive romance, Dark fantasy romance
- Blood Traitor
Blood Traitor
K. Loraine
Spice ●●●●○Dark ●●●○○
Shared: Captive romance, Dark fantasy romance
- Deceived by the Gargoyles
Deceived by the Gargoyles
Lillian Lark
Spice ●●●●●Dark ●●○○○
Shared: Monster romance, Dark fantasy romance
Books like Knotty List, with a reason for each
Questions readers actually ask
Who is the heroine in Knotty List?
Olivia, a visitor to the small town of New Obernzell, which chooses her as a sacrifice for Krampus.
Is Knotty List a standalone?
It is book one of Taylor Fox's Monster Holidays series. Each book is built around a different holiday creature.
How spicy is Knotty List?
Very explicit, at spice 5 of 5.
When did Knotty List come out?
26 November 2023.
Is Knotty List dark romance?
Yes, on the darker end of the cosy monster books. It starts with a town tying her up as a sacrifice, and darkness is 3 of 5.
Sources
- Goodreads: Knotty List (Monster Holidays #1) · used for: series number; Olivia; New Obernzell; sacrifice · checked 5 November 2026
- Amazon: Knotty List Kindle · used for: 26 Nov 2023; A Monster Romance subtitle · checked 5 November 2026
- Amazon: Monster Holidays series · used for: 3-book series · checked 5 November 2026
- Amazon paperback: Knotty List, A Dark Holiday Romance · used for: paperback subtitle · checked 5 November 2026
- Raunchy Reads: Best dark Christmas romance books · used for: blue horned Krampus; sacrifice trope; lair · checked 5 November 2026
- StoryGraph: Knotty List · used for: reader content warnings · checked 5 November 2026
Join on Patreon for the Zade Masked serial.