Dark romance · 2020
How the Hitman Stole ChristmasSpice level, tropes & is it dark romance?
by Sam Mariano
Spice 4/5 (Explicit) · Darkness 2/5 (Grey) · 4 trigger warnings flagged · Standalone
It starts with a flat tyre in a snowstorm. Jasper pulls over to help a woman on the side of the road, and by the time the tyre is sorted he has decided she is coming home with him for Christmas. Her name is Autumn. romance.io's blurb is clear: she does not get a vote.
Flat tyre, snowstorm, no choice
Jasper is a hitman, and Sam Mariano does not pretend otherwise. Her note at the front of the book, as romance.io records it, says the hero is a professional criminal and that readers who dislike antiheroes may not enjoy it. The plan is simple and mad: he needs a girlfriend for the family holidays, so he takes one. Meet New Books frames the same setup as a fake girlfriend for Christmas. The story is told from his side as well as hers, and most of it plays out over a family Christmas where Autumn has to sell the lie.
Fake girlfriend for the holidays
It is a full-length standalone. StoryGraph lists the first publication as 6 December 2020, self-published, and puts the digital edition at about 308 pages. Readers and Meet New Books both note that it touches Mariano's Morelli family world, but romance.io and the author treat it as readable on its own. You do not need any other book to follow Jasper and Autumn through the holidays.
Lighter than Descent
Meet New Books calls it lighter than her usual work. Mariano herself, again via romance.io, calls it an unconventional Christmas romance and says there is plenty of lightness, alongside dark themes that may agitate some readers. The book's tone is banter first. On an r/DarkRomance thread, readers describe it as a fluffy dark romance, and one reply put the dubious consent at the very mild end of the scale. The Trigger Warning Romance podcast flagged the aftermath of a murder and dub/non-con in its December 2022 episode.
We score darkness at 2. The kidnapping is real, but it is played for chemistry, and nothing on the page is aimed at the reader's stomach. Spice is 4: open door and explicit, which matches how romance.io files the heat.
Unverified reader flags
We could not find a full author-written list, so treat these as unverified:
- kidnapping, with the heroine taken against her will at the start
- dubious consent (reader-reported and unverified, on Reddit and the Trigger Warning Romance podcast)
- crime and a hero who kills for money
- the aftermath of a killing (reader-reported and unverified)
Soft landing or hard limit
This suits a Christmas romance with a criminal at the table and room left to laugh. For a reader new to dark romance, it is a gentle entry. If dubious consent of any kind is a hard limit, skip it, even though readers on that Reddit thread call it mild here. If you want Mariano at her darkest, start somewhere else in her backlist and come back to this one in December.
Next Christmas reads
For another Christmas killer who is more funny than frightening, try A Very Killer Christmas by Layla Fae, a novella that opens on Christmas Eve with a hitman hiding in a stranger's house. A Very Stalker Christmas is the same author's masked-neighbour story. For something longer and darker, He Sees You When You're Sleeping by Alta Hensley swaps the hitman for a firefighter who has been watching for years. More of Sam Mariano's books are on her author page, and the whole seasonal shelf is on our Christmas dark romance list.
How the Hitman Stole Christmas tropes
On this shelf, How the Hitman Stole Christmas is filed under Kidnapping romance, Morally grey heroes and Possessive heroes. Each tag opens more books with that trope.
How the Hitman Stole Christmas spice level
Is How the Hitman Stole Christmas dark romance?
Yes, but at the lighter end of the shelf. How the Hitman Stole Christmas scores 2 of 5 on our darkness scale (Grey).
Spice and darkness are separate scores. More grey books. How we rate.
How the Hitman Stole Christmas trigger warnings
Warnings not yet verified. We could not find the author's own content warning list for this book, so the flags here are only what the publisher's description makes clear. Check the author's note before you start.
Graphic (0): open before you read
Open this before you read. These are the flags most likely to be a hard stop.
None flagged in this band.
Moderate (3)
Harm, control, or obsession that is common in this lane.
Full How the Hitman Stole Christmas trigger warnings
Is How the Hitman Stole Christmas on Kindle Unlimited?
Sam Mariano is marked here as an author who often enrols titles in Kindle Unlimited. That is a shelf note, not a live Amazon check. Confirm on Amazon before you assume this book is included. More Kindle Unlimited dark romance.
Shelf notes are compiled from public sources and reader reports. Flags marked reader-reported are unverified. Outbound links are search pages, not quoted ratings. Kindle Unlimited and endings are only flagged when we were willing to mark them. How we rate.
Missing a book? Suggest it. Spotted a mistake? Report a correction.
Books like How the Hitman Stole Christmas
Matched on shared tropes, then the closest spice and darkness scores. Other books in the same series are listed above, not here.
- Twisted Pride
Twisted Pride
Cora Reilly
Spice ●●●●○Dark ●●●●○
Shared: Morally grey heroes, Possessive heroes
- Love, Utley
Love, Utley
S. J. Tilly
Spice ●●●●○Dark ●●●●○
Shared: Possessive heroes, Morally grey heroes
- Possessive Enemy
Possessive Enemy
Michelle Heard
Spice ●●●●○Dark ●●●●●
Shared: Morally grey heroes, Possessive heroes
- Ache for you
Ache for you
J. T. Geissinger
Spice ●●●●○Dark ●●●○○
Shared: Morally grey heroes, Possessive heroes
- Aquamarine Allure
Aquamarine Allure
Joanna Wylde
Spice ●●●●○Dark ●●●○○
Shared: Possessive heroes, Morally grey heroes
- Dark Clouds and Bright Skies
Dark Clouds and Bright Skies
Joanna Wylde
Spice ●●●●○Dark ●●●○○
Shared: Possessive heroes, Morally grey heroes
- King of Envy
King of Envy
Ana Huang
Spice ●●●●○Dark ●●●○○
Shared: Morally grey heroes, Possessive heroes
- Lorenzo
Lorenzo
Sadie Kincaid
Spice ●●●●○Dark ●●●○○
Shared: Morally grey heroes, Possessive heroes
Books like How the Hitman Stole Christmas, with a reason for each
Questions readers actually ask
Is How the Hitman Stole Christmas a standalone?
Yes. Sam Mariano calls it a full-length standalone. It touches her Morelli family world, but you can read it on its own.
Who are the main characters?
Jasper, a hitman, and Autumn, the woman he finds stranded in a snowstorm and takes home for Christmas as his pretend girlfriend.
How spicy is How the Hitman Stole Christmas?
Open door and explicit per romance.io. We score it spice 4 of 5.
Is there dubcon in How the Hitman Stole Christmas?
Readers report mild dubious consent. We could not find an author-written list, so that is reader-reported and unverified.
When did it come out?
6 December 2020, self-published, per StoryGraph.
Sources
- StoryGraph: How the Hitman Stole Christmas · used for: first pub 2020; 308 pages digital; self-published; 6 Dec 2020 · checked 5 November 2026
- romance.io: How the Hitman Stole Christmas · used for: blurb (Jasper, Autumn, snowstorm, flat tyre); author note (professional criminal, dark themes); standalone; explicit open door · checked 5 November 2026
- r/DarkRomance thread, 16 Dec 2024 · used for: reader views: fluffy dark romance, mild dubcon · checked 5 November 2026
- Trigger Warning Romance podcast S1E32 (26 Dec 2022) · used for: aftermath of murder; dub/non-con flags · checked 5 November 2026
- Meet New Books: How the Hitman Stole Christmas · used for: fake girlfriend for Christmas; links to Morelli family series; lighter than her usual · checked 5 November 2026
Join on Patreon for the Zade Masked serial.