Series · 3 on our shelf

The Holy Trinity series in orderMadeline Sheehan · reading order, spice & warnings

The The Holy Trinity series by Madeline Sheehan has 3 main books, plus 1 novella or bonus story. Here is the The Holy Trinity reading order with first publication years. 3 of them are on our shelf, each with spice, darkness and trigger warnings.

The Holy Trinity reading order

Book 1 The Soul Mate · 2012
Book 2 My Soul to Take · 2012
Book 2.5 · novella The Lost Souls · 2013
Book 3 My Heart and Soul not on our shelf yet

Order, numbering and years checked against the Goodreads The Holy Trinity series page on 9 October 2026. Novellas are marked; books we have not shelved yet are listed without a link.

The Holy Trinity books on our shelf

More by this author: Madeline Sheehan books in order · All dark romance series in order

Questions readers actually ask

What order should I read the The Holy Trinity series in?

Read them in series order: 1. The Soul Mate; 2. My Soul to Take; 2.5. The Lost Souls (novella); 3. My Heart and Soul. Start with The Soul Mate. The novellas are optional extras you can read after the main books around them.

How many books are in the The Holy Trinity series?

The The Holy Trinity series by Madeline Sheehan has 3 main books, plus 1 novella or bonus story.

Where should I start the The Holy Trinity series?

Start with The Soul Mate (2012). It is book 1 of 3.

Who writes the The Holy Trinity series?

Madeline Sheehan. Spice, darkness and trigger warnings for each book on our shelf are on its own page.