Series · 2 on our shelf

Tainted Hearts series in orderLylah James · reading order, spice & warnings

The Tainted Hearts series by Lylah James has 2 main books. Here is the Tainted Hearts reading order with first publication years. 2 of them are on our shelf, each with spice, darkness and trigger warnings.

Tainted Hearts reading order

Book 3 The Mafia and His Angel: Part 3 · 2017
Book 4 The Mafia and His Obsession: Part 1 · 2018

Order, numbering and years checked against the Goodreads Tainted Hearts series page on 13 October 2026. Novellas are marked; books we have not shelved yet are listed without a link.

Tainted Hearts books on our shelf

More by this author: Lylah James books in order · All dark romance series in order

Questions readers actually ask

What order should I read the Tainted Hearts series in?

Read them in series order: 3. The Mafia and His Angel: Part 3; 4. The Mafia and His Obsession: Part 1. Start with The Mafia and His Angel: Part 3.

How many books are in the Tainted Hearts series?

The Tainted Hearts series by Lylah James has 2 main books.

Where should I start the Tainted Hearts series?

Start with The Mafia and His Angel: Part 3 (2017). It is book 3 of 2.

Who writes the Tainted Hearts series?

Lylah James. Spice, darkness and trigger warnings for each book on our shelf are on its own page.